I had a good stay and recommend The Atrium.
My studio room was clean and well appointed. The only improvement would be a full size refrigerator (small fridge was OK, but, well, small).
The air conditioner was excellent.
The facility was also pretty clean and well appointed.
The pool is a gem - outstanding.
The poolside construction was pretty messy and sharp objects; screws, small snips of aluminum (potential ouch) in the pool - not good.
The gym is well equipped, but dark and dingy. Not dirty, but not appealing. With a little maintenance it could be 5-star.
The gated entry and parking are a big plus.
The staff is outstanding... pleasant, eager to help and happy (not like that everywhere on island). Thank you Garisa & Jada & others!